Hey Isaac, I have both matt and glossy surfaces in our home and both have been holding up really well.

I think contrary to popular believe that glossy surfaces are less durable, I find thats thats not true as many glossy surfaces have been treated with anti-scratch properties. They nature of glossy surfaces also makes them easier to be cleaned frequently too, unlike certain textured surfaces with grainy patterns that would sometimes traps dirt and residue within them.

End to end i would say it depends on the overall theme of your space, if its all matt (e.g matt paint walls, matt tiles) probably most it would be more consistent to keep it that way.